| A concern was expressed about whether allowing the prosecutor |
to use civil means as a method of settling a child abduction |
violated either DR 7105(A) of the Code of Professional |
Responsibility or Model Rule of Professional Responsibility 4.4. |
Both provisions either explicitly or implicitly disapprove of a |
lawyer threatening criminal action to gain an advantage in a |
civil case. However, the prohibition relates to threats that are |
solely to gain an advantage in a civil case. If the prosecutor |
has a good faith reason for pursuing the criminal action, there |
is no ethical violation. See Committee on Legal Ethics v. |
Printz, 416 S.E. 2d 720 (W.Va. 1992) (lawyer can threaten to |
press criminal charges against a client's former employee unless |
employee made restitution). |