| | | the secured party who later gives value. This result comported | | with the nemo dat concept: When the security interest attached, | | the collateral was already subject to the judicial lien. |
|
| | | On the other hand, this result treated the first secured | | advance differently from all other advances. The special rule | | for future advances in former Section 9-301(4) (substantially | | reproduced in Section 9-323(b) [Maine cite section 9-1323, | | subsection (2)]) afforded priority to a discretionary advance | | made by a secured party within 45 days after the lien creditor's | | rights arose as long as the secured party was "perfected" when | | the lien creditor's lien arose-i.e., as long as the advance was | | not the first one and an earlier advance had been made. |
|
| | | Subsection (a)(2) [Maine cite subsection (1), paragraph (b)] | | revises former Section 9-301(1)(b) and treats the first advance | | the same as subsequent advances. That is, a judicial lien that | | arises after a financing statement is filed and before the | | security interest attaches and becomes perfected is subordinate | | to all advances secured by the security interest, even the first | | advance, except as otherwise provided in Section 9-323(b) [Maine | | cite section 9-1323, subsection (2)]. However, if the security | | interest becomes unperfected (e.g., because the effectiveness of | | the filed financing statement lapses) before the judicial lien | | arises, the security interest is subordinate. If a financing | | statement is filed but a security interest does not attach, then | | no priority contest arises. The lien creditor has the only claim | | to the property. |
|
| | | 5. Security Interest of Consignor or Receivables Buyer vs. | | Lien Creditor. Section 1-201(37) defines "security interest" to | | include the interest of most true consignors of goods and the | | interest of most buyers of certain receivables (accounts, chattel | | paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes). A consignee | | of goods or a seller of accounts or chattel paper each is deemed | | to have rights in the collateral which a lien creditor may reach, | | as long as the competing security interest of the consignor or | | buyer is unperfected. This is so even though, as between the | | consignor and the debtor-consignee, the latter has only limited | | rights, and, as between the buyer and debtor-seller, the latter | | does not have any rights in the collateral. See Sections 9-318 | | [Maine cite section 9-1318] (seller), 9-319 [Maine cite section | | 9-1319] (consignee). Security interests arising from sales of | | payment intangibles and promissory notes are automatically | | perfected. See Section 9-309 [Maine cite section 9-1309]. | | Accordingly, a subsequent judicial lien always would be | | subordinate to the rights of a buyer of those types of | | receivables. |
|
|