LD 2245
pg. 182
Page 181 of 493 An Act to Adopt the Model Revised Article 9 Secured Transactions Page 183 of 493
Download Bill Text
LR 1087
Item 1

 
the secured party who later gives value. This result comported
with the nemo dat concept: When the security interest attached,
the collateral was already subject to the judicial lien.

 
On the other hand, this result treated the first secured
advance differently from all other advances. The special rule
for future advances in former Section 9-301(4) (substantially
reproduced in Section 9-323(b) [Maine cite section 9-1323,
subsection (2)]) afforded priority to a discretionary advance
made by a secured party within 45 days after the lien creditor's
rights arose as long as the secured party was "perfected" when
the lien creditor's lien arose-i.e., as long as the advance was
not the first one and an earlier advance had been made.

 
Subsection (a)(2) [Maine cite subsection (1), paragraph (b)]
revises former Section 9-301(1)(b) and treats the first advance
the same as subsequent advances. That is, a judicial lien that
arises after a financing statement is filed and before the
security interest attaches and becomes perfected is subordinate
to all advances secured by the security interest, even the first
advance, except as otherwise provided in Section 9-323(b) [Maine
cite section 9-1323, subsection (2)]. However, if the security
interest becomes unperfected (e.g., because the effectiveness of
the filed financing statement lapses) before the judicial lien
arises, the security interest is subordinate. If a financing
statement is filed but a security interest does not attach, then
no priority contest arises. The lien creditor has the only claim
to the property.

 
5. Security Interest of Consignor or Receivables Buyer vs.
Lien Creditor. Section 1-201(37) defines "security interest" to
include the interest of most true consignors of goods and the
interest of most buyers of certain receivables (accounts, chattel
paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes). A consignee
of goods or a seller of accounts or chattel paper each is deemed
to have rights in the collateral which a lien creditor may reach,
as long as the competing security interest of the consignor or
buyer is unperfected. This is so even though, as between the
consignor and the debtor-consignee, the latter has only limited
rights, and, as between the buyer and debtor-seller, the latter
does not have any rights in the collateral. See Sections 9-318
[Maine cite section 9-1318] (seller), 9-319 [Maine cite section
9-1319] (consignee). Security interests arising from sales of
payment intangibles and promissory notes are automatically
perfected. See Section 9-309 [Maine cite section 9-1309].
Accordingly, a subsequent judicial lien always would be
subordinate to the rights of a buyer of those types of
receivables.


Page 181 of 493 Top of Page Page 183 of 493