LD 2245
pg. 232
Page 231 of 493 An Act to Adopt the Model Revised Article 9 Secured Transactions Page 233 of 493
Download Bill Text
LR 1087
Item 1

 
XYZ Co. stock. Debtor instructs Able to have the 1000 shares
transferred through the clearing corporation to Custodian Bank,
to be credited to Beta's account with Custodian Bank. Alpha and
Beta both have perfected security interests in the XYZ Co. stock.
Beta has control, see Section 8-106(d)(1) [Maine cite section 8-
1106, subsection (4), paragraph (a)], and hence has priority over
Alpha.

 
Example 3: Debtor borrows from Alpha and grants Alpha a
security interest in a variety of collateral, including all of
Debtor's investment property. At that time Debtor owns 1000
shares of XYZ Co. stock, which is held through a securities
account with Able & Co. Alpha perfects by filing. Later, Debtor
borrows from Beta and grants Beta a security interest in the 1000
shares of XYZ Co. stock. Debtor, Able, and Beta enter into an
agreement under which Debtor will continue to receive dividends
and distributions, and will continue to have the right to direct
dispositions, but Beta will also have the right to direct
dispositions and receive the proceeds. Alpha and Beta both have
perfected security interests in the XYZ Co. stock (more
precisely, in the Debtor's security entitlement to the financial
asset consisting of the XYZ Co. stock). Beta has control, see
Section 8-106(d)(2) [Maine cite section 8-1106, subsection (4),
paragraph (b)], and hence has priority over Alpha.

 
Example 4: Debtor borrows from Alpha and grants Alpha a
security interest in a variety of collateral, including all of
Debtor's investment property. At that time Debtor owns 1000
shares of XYZ Co. stock, held through a securities account with
Able & Co. Alpha perfects by filing. Debtor's agreement with
Able & Co. provides that Able has a security interest in all
securities carried in the account as security for any obligations
of Debtor to Able. Debtor incurs obligations to Able and later
defaults on the obligations to Alpha and Able. Able has control
by virtue of the rule of Section 8-106(e) [Maine cite section 8-
1106, subsection (5)] that if a customer grants a security
interest to its own intermediary, the intermediary has control.
Since Alpha does not have control, Able has priority over Alpha
under the general control priority rule of paragraph (1) [Maine
cite subsection (1)].

 
4. Conflicting Security Interests Perfected by Control:
Priority of Securities Intermediary or Commodity Intermediary.
Paragraphs (2) through (4) [Maine cite subsections (2) to (4)]
govern the priority of conflicting security interests each of
which is perfected by control. The following example explains
the application of the rules in paragraphs (3) and (4) [Maine
cite subsections (3) and (4)]:


Page 231 of 493 Top of Page Page 233 of 493