| XYZ Co. stock. Debtor instructs Able to have the 1000 shares | transferred through the clearing corporation to Custodian Bank, | to be credited to Beta's account with Custodian Bank. Alpha and | Beta both have perfected security interests in the XYZ Co. stock. | Beta has control, see Section 8-106(d)(1) [Maine cite section 8- | 1106, subsection (4), paragraph (a)], and hence has priority over | Alpha. |
|
| | Example 3: Debtor borrows from Alpha and grants Alpha a | security interest in a variety of collateral, including all of | Debtor's investment property. At that time Debtor owns 1000 | shares of XYZ Co. stock, which is held through a securities | account with Able & Co. Alpha perfects by filing. Later, Debtor | borrows from Beta and grants Beta a security interest in the 1000 | shares of XYZ Co. stock. Debtor, Able, and Beta enter into an | agreement under which Debtor will continue to receive dividends | and distributions, and will continue to have the right to direct | dispositions, but Beta will also have the right to direct | dispositions and receive the proceeds. Alpha and Beta both have | perfected security interests in the XYZ Co. stock (more | precisely, in the Debtor's security entitlement to the financial | asset consisting of the XYZ Co. stock). Beta has control, see | Section 8-106(d)(2) [Maine cite section 8-1106, subsection (4), | paragraph (b)], and hence has priority over Alpha. |
|
| | Example 4: Debtor borrows from Alpha and grants Alpha a | security interest in a variety of collateral, including all of | Debtor's investment property. At that time Debtor owns 1000 | shares of XYZ Co. stock, held through a securities account with | Able & Co. Alpha perfects by filing. Debtor's agreement with | Able & Co. provides that Able has a security interest in all | securities carried in the account as security for any obligations | of Debtor to Able. Debtor incurs obligations to Able and later | defaults on the obligations to Alpha and Able. Able has control | by virtue of the rule of Section 8-106(e) [Maine cite section 8- | 1106, subsection (5)] that if a customer grants a security | interest to its own intermediary, the intermediary has control. | Since Alpha does not have control, Able has priority over Alpha | under the general control priority rule of paragraph (1) [Maine | cite subsection (1)]. |
|
| | 4. Conflicting Security Interests Perfected by Control: | Priority of Securities Intermediary or Commodity Intermediary. | Paragraphs (2) through (4) [Maine cite subsections (2) to (4)] | govern the priority of conflicting security interests each of | which is perfected by control. The following example explains | the application of the rules in paragraphs (3) and (4) [Maine | cite subsections (3) and (4)]: |
|
|