| | | a surplus. Because Section 9-626 [Maine cite section 9-1626] | | does not apply to consumer transactions, the statute is silent as | | to whether a double recovery or other over-compensation is | | possible in a consumer transaction. |
|
| | | Damages for violation of the requirements of this Article, | | including Section 9-609 [Maine cite section 9-1609], are those | | reasonably calculated to put an eligible claimant in the position | | that it would have occupied had no violation occurred. See | | Section 1-106. Subsection (b) [Maine cite subsection (2)] | | supports the recovery of actual damages for committing a breach | | of the peace in violation of Section 9-609 [Maine cite section 9- | | 1609], and principles of tort law supplement this subsection. | | See Section 1-103. However, to the extent that damages in tort | | compensate the debtor for the same loss dealt with by this | | Article, the debtor should be entitled to only one recovery. |
|
| | | 4. Minimum Damages in Consumer-Goods Transactions. | | Subsection (c)(2) [Maine cite subsection (3), paragraph (b)] | | provides a minimum, statutory, damage recovery for a debtor and | | secondary obligor in a consumer-goods transaction. It is | | patterned on former Section 9-507(1) and is designed to ensure | | that every noncompliance with the requirements of Part 6 in a | | consumer-goods transaction results in liability, regardless of | | any injury that may have resulted. Subsection (c)(2) [Maine cite | | subsection (3), paragraph (b)] leaves the treatment of statutory | | damages as it was under former Article 9. A secured party is not | | liable for statutory damages under this subsection more than once | | with respect to any one secured obligation. See Section 9-628(e) | | [Maine cite section 9-1628, subsection (5)]. Nor is a secured | | party liable under this subsection for failure to comply with | | Section 9-616 [Maine cite section 9-1616]. See Section 9-628(d) | | [Maine cite section 9-1628, subsection (4)]. |
|
| | | Following former Section 9-507(1), this Article does not | | include a definition or explanation of the terms "credit service | | charge," "principal amount," "time-price differential," or "cash | | price," as used in subsection (c)(2) [Maine cite subsection (3), | | paragraph (b)]. It leaves their construction and application to | | the court, taking into account the subsection's purpose of | | providing a minimum recovery in consumer-goods transactions. |
|
| | | 5. Supplemental Damages. Subsections (e) and (f) [Maine cite | | subsections (5) and (6)] provide damages that supplement the | | recovery, if any, under subsection (b) [Maine cite subsection | | (2)]. Subsection (e) [Maine cite subsection (5)] imposes an | | additional $500 liability upon a person who fails to comply with | | the provisions specified in that subsection, and subsection (f) | | [Maine cite subsection (6)] imposes like damages on a person who, | | without reasonable excuse, fails to comply with a request for an |
|
|