LD 2245
pg. 71
Page 70 of 493 An Act to Adopt the Model Revised Article 9 Secured Transactions Page 72 of 493
Download Bill Text
LR 1087
Item 1

 
nominated persons may give or be obligated to give value under a
letter of credit, this section contemplates that a secured party
obtains control of a letter-of-credit right with respect to the
issuer or a particular nominated person only to the extent that
the issuer or that nominated person consents to the assignment.
For example, if a secured party obtains control to the extent of
an issuer's obligation but fails to obtain the consent of a
nominated person, the secured party does not have control to the
extent that the nominated person gives value. In many cases the
person or persons who will give value under a letter of credit
will be clear from its terms. In other cases, prudence may
suggest obtaining consent from more than one person. The details
of the consenting issuer's or nominated person's duties to pay or
otherwise render performance to the secured party are left to the
agreement of the parties.

 
3. "Proceeds of a Letter of Credit." Section 5-114 follows
traditional banking terminology by referring to a letter of
credit beneficiary's assignment of its right to receive payment
thereunder as an assignment of the "proceeds of a letter of
credit." However, as the seller of goods can assign its right to
receive payment (an "account") before it has been earned by
delivering the goods to the buyer, so the beneficiary of a letter
of credit can assign its contingent right to payment before the
letter of credit has been honored. See Section 5-114(b). If the
assignment creates a security interest, the security interest can
be perfected at the time it is created. An assignment of,
including the creation of a security interest in, a letter-of-
credit right is an assignment of a present interest.

 
4. "Transfer" vs. "Assignment." Letter-of-credit law and
practice distinguish the "transfer" of a letter of credit from an
"assignment." Under a transfer, the transferee itself becomes
the beneficiary and acquires the right to draw. Whether a new,
substitute credit is issued or the issuer advises the transferee
of its status as such, the transfer constitutes a novation under
which the transferee is the new, substituted beneficiary (but
only to the extent of the transfer, in the case of a partial
transfer).

 
Section 5-114(e) provides that the rights of a transferee
beneficiary or nominated person are independent of the
beneficiary's assignment of the proceeds of a letter of credit
and are superior to the assignee's right to the proceeds. For
this reason, transfer does not appear in this Article as a means
of control or perfection. Section 9-109(c)(4) [Maine cite
section 9-1109, subsection (3), paragraph (d)] recognizes the
independent and superior rights of a transferee beneficiary under
Section 5-114(e); this Article does not apply to the rights of a


Page 70 of 493 Top of Page Page 72 of 493