LD 1494
pg. 2
Page 1 of 2 An Act to Require Parental Notification of Abortion LD 1494 Title Page
Download Bill Text
LR 2107
Item 1

 
notification of her parent shall file a petition in a trial court,
as defined in section 8401, requesting the issuance of an order
authorizing her to consent to the performance or inducement of an
abortion without the notification of her parent.

 
2.__Petition requirements.__The petition must be made under
oath and must include all of the following:

 
A.__A statement that the petitioner is pregnant;

 
B.__A statement that the petitioner is unemancipated;

 
C.__A statement that the petitioner wishes to have an
abortion without the notification of her parent;

 
D.__An allegation of one or both of the following:

 
(1)__That the petitioner is sufficiently mature and
informed to intelligently decide whether to have an
abortion without the notification of her parent; or

 
(2)__That the petitioner's parent was engaged in a
pattern of physical, sexual or emotional abuse against
her or that the notification of her parent otherwise is
not in her best interest; and

 
E.__A statement as to whether the petitioner has retained an
attorney and, if she has retained an attorney, the name,
address and telephone number of her attorney.

 
§8403.__Procedural provisions

 
1.__Hearing; judgment; constructive order.__The court shall
fix a time for a hearing on any petition filed under this chapter
and shall keep a record of all testimony and other oral
proceedings in the action.__The court shall hear and determine
the action and may not refer any portion of it to a referee.__The
hearing must be held at the earliest possible time, but not later
than the 5th business day after the day that the petition is
filed.__The court shall enter judgment on the petition
immediately after the hearing is concluded.__If the hearing
required by this section is not held by the 5th business day
after the petition is filed, the failure to hold the hearing is
deemed to be a constructive order of the court authorizing the
petitioner to consent to the performance or inducement of an
abortion without the notification of her parent, and the
petitioner and any other person may rely on the constructive
order as if the court actually had issued an order under this
section authorizing the petitioner to consent to the performance
or inducement of an abortion without the notification of her
parent.

 
2.__Guardian ad litem.__The court shall appoint a guardian ad
litem to protect the interests of the petitioner at the hearing
that is held pursuant to this section.__If the petitioner has not
retained an attorney, the court shall appoint an attorney to
represent her.__If the guardian ad litem is an attorney admitted
to practice law in the State, the court may appoint the guardian
ad litem to serve also as the petitioner's attorney.

 
§8404.__Standards of review

 
1.__Allegation of competence.__If the petitioner makes only
the allegation set forth in section 8402, subsection 2, paragraph
D, subparagraph (1) and if the court finds, by clear and
convincing evidence, that the petitioner is sufficiently mature
and informed to decide intelligently whether to have an abortion,
the court shall issue an order authorizing the petitioner to
consent to the performance or inducement of an abortion without
the notification of her parent.__If the court does not make such
a finding, the court shall dismiss the petition.

 
2.__Allegation of abuse.__If the petitioner makes only the
allegation set forth in section 8402, subsection 2, paragraph D,
subparagraph (2) and if the court finds, by clear and convincing
evidence, that there is evidence of a pattern of physical, sexual
or emotional abuse of the petitioner by a parent or that the
notification of the parent of the petitioner otherwise is not in
the best interest of the petitioner, the court shall issue an
order authorizing the petitioner to consent to the performance or
inducement of an abortion without the notification of her parent.__
If the court does not make such a finding, the court shall
dismiss the petition.

 
3.__Allegations of competence and abuse.__If the petitioner
makes both of the allegations set forth in section 8402,
subsection 2, paragraph D, subparagraphs (1) and (2), the court
shall proceed as follows.

 
A.__The court first shall determine whether it can make the
finding specified in subsection 1 and, if so, shall issue an
order pursuant to that subsection.__If the court issues such
an order, it may not review the allegation made under
section 8402, subsection 2, paragraph D, subparagraph (2).__
If the court does not make the finding specified in
subsection 1, it shall review the allegation made under
section 8402, subsection 2, paragraph D, subparagraph (2).

 
B.__If the court pursuant to paragraph A does not make the
finding specified in subsection 1, it shall determine
whether it can make the finding specified in subsection 2
and, if so, shall issue an order pursuant to that
subsection.__If the court does not make the finding
specified in subsection 2, the court shall dismiss the
petition.

 
§8405.__Miscellaneous provisions

 
1.__Notice prohibited.__The court may not notify the parent of
the petitioner that the petitioner is pregnant or that she wants
to have an abortion.

 
2.__Notice of right to appeal.__If the court dismisses the
petition, it immediately shall notify the petitioner that she has
a right to appeal pursuant to section 8406.

 
3.__Confidentiality.__Each hearing under section 8403 must be
conducted in a manner that will preserve the anonymity of the
petitioner.__The petition and all other papers and records that
pertain to an action commenced under this chapter are
confidential and are not public records under Title 1, chapter 13
or any other provision of law.

 
4.__Forms.__The Supreme Judicial Court shall prescribe
petition and notice of appeal forms to be used by a petitioner
filing a petition under this section and by an appellant filing
an appeal.__The clerk of each trial court shall furnish blank
copies of the forms, without charge, to any person who requests
them.

 
5.__Filing fee.__A filing fee may not be required of and court
costs may not be assessed against a petitioner filing a petition
under section 8402 or an appellant filing an appeal pursuant to
section 8406.

 
6.__Presumed unemancipated.__For purposes of prosecutions for
a violation of Title 22, section 1600-A, it is a rebuttable
presumption that a woman who is unmarried and under 18 years of
age is unemancipated.

 
§8406.__Appeal

 
A petitioner whose petition under this chapter is dismissed by
the Probate Court or District Court may appeal in accordance with
this section.

 
1.__Docketing of appeal.__Within 4 days after a notice of
appeal is filed in an action arising under this chapter, the
clerk of the trial court shall deliver a copy of the notice of
appeal and the record on appeal to the Clerk of the Supreme
Judicial Court named in the notice.__Upon receipt of the notice
and record, the Clerk of the Supreme Judicial Court shall place
the appeal on the docket of the court.

 
2.__Briefs and decision.__The appellant's brief must be filed
within 4 days after the appeal is docketed.__Unless the appellant
waives the right to oral argument, the Supreme Judicial Court
shall hear oral argument within 5 days after the appeal is
docketed.__The Supreme Judicial Court shall enter judgment on the
appeal immediately after the oral argument or, if oral argument
has been waived, within 5 days after the appeal is docketed.

 
3.__Filing fee.__A filing fee may not be required of and court
costs may not be assessed against an appellant who appeals under
this section.

 
4.__Procedures; constructive order.__Upon motion of the
appellant and for good cause shown, the Supreme Judicial Court
may shorten or extend any of the maximum times set forth in this
section.__If judgment is not entered within 5 days after the
appeal is docketed, the failure to enter judgment is deemed to be
a constructive order of the court authorizing the appellant to
consent to the performance or inducement of an abortion without
the notification of her parent and the appellant and any other
person may rely on the constructive order as if the court
actually had entered judgment under this section authorizing the
appellant to consent to the performance or inducement of an
abortion without the notification of her parent.

 
In the interest of justice, the Supreme Judicial Court, in an
appeal under this section, shall liberally modify or dispense
with the formal requirements that normally apply to the contents
and form of an appellant's brief.

 
5.__Confidentiality.__All proceedings under this section must
be conducted in a manner that will preserve the anonymity of the
appellant on appeal.__The notice of appeal and all papers and
records that pertain to an appeal under this section are
confidential and are not public records under Title 1, chapter 13
or any other provision of law.

 
Sec. 3. 22 MRSA c. 263-B is amended by repealing the chapter
headnote and enacting the following in its place:

 
CHAPTER 263-B

 
ABORTIONS

 
SUBCHAPTER I

 
ABORTIONS GENERALLY

 
Sec. 4. 22 MRSA §1597-A, as amended by PL 1993, c. 600, Pt. B, §21,
is repealed.

 
Sec. 5. 22 MRSA §1598, sub-§1, as amended by PL 1993, c. 61, §2, is
further amended to read:

 
1. Policy. It is the public policy of the State that the
State not restrict a woman's exercise of her private decision to
terminate a pregnancy before viability except as provided in
section 1597-A Title 14, chapter 751. After viability an
abortion may be performed only when it is necessary to preserve
the life or health of the mother. It is also the public policy of
the State that all abortions may be performed only by a
physician.

 
Sec. 6. 22 MRSA c. 263-B, sub-c. II is enacted to read:

 
SUBCHAPTER II

 
ABORTIONS FOR MINORS

 
§1600.__Definitions

 
As used in this subchapter, unless the context otherwise
indicates, the following terms have the following meanings.

 
1.__Parent.__"Parent" means one of a pregnant woman's parents
or a guardian or custodian.

 
2.__Physician.__"Physician" means a person licensed under
Title 32, chapter 36 or 48 to practice medicine in the State as a
medical or osteopathic physician.

 
3.__Specified relative.__"Specified relative" means a brother
or sister who is 21 years of age or older or a stepparent or
grandparent of a pregnant woman.

 
4.__Trial court.__"Trial court" means a District Court in
whose district a pregnant woman has her residence, a District
Court in whose district a hospital, clinic or other facility in
which an abortion would be performed or induced is located, a
Probate Court in whose county a pregnant woman has her residence
or a Probate Court in whose county a hospital, clinic or other
facility in which an abortion would be performed or induced is
located.

 
5.__Unemancipated.__"Unemancipated" means a woman who is
unmarried, is under 18 years of age, is not in the Armed Forces
of the United States and is not employed full time and self-
subsisting or otherwise independent from the care and control of
her parent.

 
§1600-A.__Parental consent required

 
A physician may not knowingly perform or induce an abortion
for an unemancipated pregnant woman unless at least one of the
following applies.

 
1.__Notice given.__Subject to this section, the physician has
given at least 24 hours' actual notice, in person or by
telephone, to the woman's parent of the intention to perform or
induce the abortion, except that, if the pregnant woman has
requested that notice be given to a specified relative in
accordance with section 1600-C and if the physician is notified
by a court that affidavits described in section 1600-C have been
filed with that court, the 24 hours' actual notice described in
this section of the intention to perform or induce the abortion
must be given, in person or by telephone, to the specified
relative instead of to the parent.

 
2.__Written consent.__The pregnant woman's parent has
consented in writing to the performance or inducement of the
abortion.

 
3.__Court order.__A court pursuant to Title 14, chapter 751
issues an order authorizing the pregnant woman to consent to the
abortion without notification of her parent.

 
4.__Constructive order.__The failure to hold the hearing
pursuant to Title 14, section 8403 is deemed to be a constructive
order of the court authorizing the pregnant woman to consent to
the performance or inducement of an abortion without the
notification of the pregnant woman's parent, and the pregnant
woman and any other person may rely on the constructive order as
if the court actually had issued an order under this section
authorizing the pregnant woman to consent to the performance or
inducement of an abortion without the notification of her parent
pursuant to Title 14, section 8403, subsection 1 or Title 14,
section 8406, subsection 4.

 
§1600-B.__Coercion prohibited

 
A parent or any other person may not coerce an unemancipated
pregnant woman to have an abortion performed or induced.__If the
pregnant woman is denied financial support by her parent due to
her refusal to have an abortion performed or induced, the
pregnant woman is deemed emancipated for the purposes of
eligibility for public assistance benefits, except that the
benefits may not be used to obtain an abortion.

 
§1600-C.__Consent of specified relative

 
If an unemancipated pregnant woman desires that notification
of a physician's intention to perform or induce an abortion on
that pregnant woman be given to a specified relative instead of
to her parent, the physician who intends to perform or induce the
abortion shall notify the specified relative instead of the
parent for purposes of section 1600-A, subsection 1 if all of the
following apply:

 
1.__Identification reviewed.__The pregnant woman has requested
that the physician provide notification to the specified relative
and has identified clearly the specified relative and her
relation to that person;

 
2.__Affidavit of pregnant woman required.__The pregnant woman
has:

 
A.__Executed an affidavit stating that she is in fear of
physical, sexual or severe emotional abuse from her parent
who otherwise would be notified under section 1600-A,
subsection 1 and that the fear is based on a pattern of
physical, sexual or severe emotional abuse exhibited by that
parent;

 
B.__Filed the affidavit with the trial court that has
jurisdiction over the county or district in which the
pregnant woman has a residence or the trial court having
jurisdiction over the county or district in which the
hospital, clinic or other facility in which the abortion
would be performed or induced is located; and

 
C.__Given the court written notice of the name and address
of the physician who intends to perform or induce the
abortion;

 
3.__Affidavit of specified relative required.__The specified
relative has executed an affidavit stating that the pregnant
woman has reason to fear physical, sexual or severe emotional
abuse from the parent who otherwise would be notified under
section 1600-A, subsection 1 based on a pattern of physical,
sexual or severe emotional abuse by that parent and the pregnant
woman has filed with the trial court the affidavit described in
subsection 2; and

 
4.__Filing of affidavits.__The trial court in which the
affidavits described in subsections 2 and 3 were filed has
notified the physician that both affidavits have been filed with
the court.

 
A physician shall file a monthly report indicating the number
of notices issued under this subchapter and the number of times
in which exceptions were made to the notice requirement under
this section, as well as the type of exception, with the
department on forms prescribed by the department.__A patient's
name may not be used on the forms.__A compilation of the data
reported must be made by the department on an annual basis and
must be available to the public.

 
§1600-D.__Documentation; notice

 
If an affidavit described in section 1600-C, subsection 2 and
an affidavit described in section 1600-C, subsection 3 are filed
with a trial court and the court has been provided with written
notice of the name and address of the physician who intends to
perform or induce an abortion for the pregnant woman to whom the
affidavits pertain, the court promptly shall notify the physician
who intends to perform or induce the abortion that the affidavits
have been filed.__The notice to the physician must be given in
person or by telephone.

 
1.__Failure of notice.__If the parent can not be reached for
purposes of section 1600-A, subsection 1 after a reasonable
effort or if notification is to be given to a specified relative
under section 1600-C and the specified relative can not be
reached for purposes of section 1600-A, subsection 1 after a
reasonable effort, a physician may not perform or induce an
abortion without giving at least 48 hours' constructive notice to
the parent by both certified and ordinary mail sent to the last
known address of the parent or, if notification for purposes of
section 1600-C is to be given to a specified relative, without
giving at least 48 hours' constructive notice to that specified
relative by both certified and ordinary mail sent to the last
known address of that specified relative.__The 48-hour period
begins when the certified mail notice is received and signed for
by the parent or the specified relative.__If the parent of the
pregnant woman or the specified relative, if notification under
section 1600-C is to be given to a specified relative, is not
reached within a 48-hour period, the abortion may be performed or
induced even if the certified mail notice is not received.

 
If the parent or the specified relative who has been notified in
accordance with section 1600-C clearly and unequivocally
expresses a decision not to consult with the pregnant woman
before the pregnant woman's abortion, then the abortion may be
performed or induced without any further waiting period.

 
§1600-E.__Unlawful abortion

 
A physician who violates section 1600-A commits unlawful
abortion, which is a Class D crime.__If the offender previously
has been convicted of a violation of section 1600-A, unlawful
abortion is a Class C crime.

 
A physician who violates the provisions of this subchapter
commits unprofessional conduct, and the physician's license to
practice is subject to suspension or revocation in accordance
with the procedures provided under Title 32, chapter 36,
subchapter V or Title 32, chapter 48, subchapter II.

 
§1600-F.__Violation; penalties

 
A person who violates the provisions of this subchapter is
liable to the pregnant woman and the pregnant woman's parent for
civil compensatory and punitive damages.

 
§1600-G.__Affirmative defenses

 
1.__False, misleading or incorrect information.__It is an
affirmative defense to a charge under section 1600-E that the
pregnant woman provided the physician who performed or induced
the abortion with false, misleading or incorrect information
about the pregnant woman's age, marital status or emancipation,
about the age of a brother or sister to whom the pregnant woman
requested notice be given as a specified relative instead of the
pregnant woman's parent or about the last known phone number and
address of the pregnant woman's parent or the specified relative
to whom the pregnant woman requested notice be given and that the
physician who performed or induced the abortion did not otherwise
have reasonable cause to believe that the pregnant woman was
under 18 years of age, unmarried or unemancipated, that the
brother or sister to whom she requested notice be given as a
specified relative was not 21 years of age or that the last known
phone number and address of the pregnant woman's parent or
specified relative were incorrect.

 
2.__Immediate threat of serious risk.__It is an affirmative
defense to a charge under section 1600-E that compliance with the
requirements of section 1600-A was not possible because an
immediate threat of serious risk to the life or physical health
of the pregnant woman from the continuation of the pregnancy
created an emergency necessitating the immediate performance or
inducement of an abortion.

 
SUMMARY

 
This bill requires parental notification before an abortion is
performed or induced on a pregnant minor.

 
The bill requires that notification be provided to one parent
or, when the minor is in fear of physical, sexual or emotional
abuse from a parent, to a specified relative, who may be a
grandparent, a stepparent or a sister or brother who is 21 years
of age or older.

 
The bill also allows for alternative procedures whereby the
minor may seek court approval for the proposed abortion and
establishes the procedures for judicial review and appeals.


Page 1 of 2 Top of Page LD 1494 Title Page