| | |
person. The bill also strikes an exception relative to use of | | nonconforming forms that no longer is relevant. |
|
| | | The bill addresses a defect in the statute prohibiting | | obstruction of government administration revealed by the recent | | case of State v. Matson, 2003 ME 34, 818 A.2d 213. In Matson, | | the defendant had been convicted under the statute for physically | | interfering with the arrest of another person. Because the | | physical interference, intentionally standing in the way and | | refusing to move, was held to constitute something less than | | "force, violence or intimidation," the conviction was reversed. |
|
| | | The focus of the crime is intentional physical interference | | with an official function, not "intimidation" of an officer. | | Harassing speech alone is not sufficient, but when it is | | accompanied by a physical act that actually interferes with an | | official function, the further requirement of "intimidation" is | | unnecessary. |
|
| | | The bill repeals Title 17-A, section 1158 and replaces it with | | section 1158-A, which differs in the following ways. |
|
| | | 1. It makes technical drafting changes to clarify the law. |
|
| | | 2. It clarifies that forfeiture of a firearm under certain | | circumstances is conditioned on the State's both alleging | | that the firearm was used by the defendant or an accomplice | | during the commission of the crime in the indictment or | | information and proving that allegation to the fact finder | | beyond a reasonable doubt. |
|
| | | 3. It clarifies when a court may not order as part of the | | sentence the forfeiture of a firearm otherwise qualifying | | for forfeiture. Access to the exception is available only | | to a person other than the defendant. The exception must be | | established by the other person at a point in time prior to | | the actual imposition of the defendant's sentence, and the | | burden imposed on the other person is to satisfy the court | | of the exception by a preponderance of the evidence. |
|
| | | The bill also addresses forfeiture of firearms other than in | | the context of a conviction under possession of a firearm by a | | prohibited person or in the context of a handgun used by the | | defendant or an accomplice during the commission of murder or any | | other unlawful homicide crime. The other person's burden is | | satisfied by proof by a preponderance of the evidence that at the | | time of the commission of the crime, the other person had a right | | to possess the firearm to the exclusion of the defendant. This | | burden is the same as under Title 17-A, section 1158. |
|
|