LD 1851
pg. 38
Page 37 of 90 An Act To Implement the Recommendations of the Family Law Advisory Commission w... Page 39 of 90
Download Bill Text
LR 2675
Item 1

 
(2)__Engage another testing laboratory to perform the
calculations.

 
C.__The testing laboratory may use its own statistical
estimate if there is a question regarding which ethnic or
racial group is appropriate. If available, the testing
laboratory shall calculate the frequencies using statistics
for any other ethnic or racial group requested.

 
4.__Additional genetic testing.__If, after recalculation using
a different ethnic or racial group, genetic testing does not
rebuttably identify a man as the father of a child under section
1905, an individual who has been tested may be required to submit
to additional genetic testing.

 
Comment

 
(This is section 503 of the UPA.)

 
Source: 42 U.S.C. §§ 666(a)(5)(B)(i)(I)(II) and
666(a)(5)(F)(i)(I)(II), see Appendix: Federal IV-D Statute
Relating to Parentage, infra.

 
As of December 2000, the Secretary of Health and Human
Services had not officially designated any accreditation bodies
as referenced in subsection (b)(3). But, Information Memorandum
OCSE-IM-97-03, April 10, 1997, from the Deputy Director of the
Office of Child Support Enforcement identifies the American
Association of Blood Banks and American Society for
Histocompatibility and Immunogenetics as meeting this
requirement. The accreditation requirement assures that the
testing will "be of a type reasonably relied upon by experts in
the field of genetic testing."

 
Subsection (b) clarifies that a "specimen" suitable for
genetic testing may be composed from one of a wide variety of
constituent elements of "body tissue and fluids." This conforms
the statutory language to biological terminology to assure common
understanding between the scientific community and the legal
profession. In states with statutes employing only the broad
terms, bench and bar have evidenced confusion about the fact that
blood, buccal cells, bone, hair, etc. are "body tissues."

 
Subsections (c) and (d) are designed to clarify the use of
"race or ethnic group" in the paternity calculations. Generally,
the individual tested provides the information regarding the
ethnic or racial group to use in the calculations. These sections
are designed to avoid last minute changes in the racial
designation, a scientific version of "forum shopping", and to


Page 37 of 90 Top of Page Page 39 of 90