LD 2245
pg. 236
Page 235 of 493 An Act to Adopt the Model Revised Article 9 Secured Transactions Page 237 of 493
Download Bill Text
LR 1087
Item 1

 
provided to the lender on a daily basis, that the debtor will
deliver the securities to the lender on demand, and that the
debtor will not list as collateral any securities which the
debtor has pledged to any other lender. Upon Able's insolvency
it is discovered that Able has listed the same securities on the
collateral lists provided to both Alpha and Beta. Alpha and Beta
both have perfected security interests under the automatic-
perfection rule of Section 9-309(10) [Maine cite section 9-1309,
subsection (10)]. Neither Alpha nor Beta has control. Paragraph
(6) [Maine cite subsection (6)] provides that the security
interests of Alpha and Beta rank equally, because each of them
has a non-control security interest granted by a securities firm.
They share pro-rata.

 
Example 8: Able enters into financing arrangements, with
Alpha Bank and Beta Bank as in Example 7. At some point,
however, Beta decides that it is unwilling to continue to provide
financing on a non-control basis. Able directs the clearing
corporation where it holds its principal inventory of securities
to move specified securities into Beta's account. Upon Able's
insolvency it is discovered that a list of collateral provided to
Alpha includes securities that had been moved to Beta's account.
Both Alpha and Beta have perfected security interests; Alpha
under the automatic-perfection rule of Section 9-309(10) [Maine
cite section 9-1309, subsection (10)], and Beta under that rule
and also the perfection-by-control rule in Section 9-314(a)
[Maine cite section 9-1314, subsection (a)]. Beta has control
but Alpha does not. Beta has priority over Alpha under paragraph
(1) [Maine cite subsection (1)].

 
Example 9: Able & Co. carries its principal inventory of
securities through Clearing Corporation, which offers a "shared
control" facility whereby a participant securities firm can enter
into an arrangement with a lender under which the securities firm
will retain the power to trade and otherwise direct dispositions
of securities carried in its account, but Clearing Corporation
agrees that, at any time the lender so directs, Clearing
Corporation will transfer any securities from the firm's account
to the lender's account or otherwise dispose of them as directed
by the lender. Able enters into financing arrangements with two
lenders, Alpha and Beta, each of which obtains such a control
agreement from Clearing Corporation. The agreement with each
lender provides that Able will designate specific securities as
collateral on lists provided to the lender on a daily or other
periodic basis, and that it will not pledge the same securities
to different lenders. Upon Able's insolvency, it is discovered
that Able has listed the same securities on the collateral lists
provided to both Alpha and Beta. Both Alpha and Beta have
control over the disputed securities. Paragraph (2) [Maine cite


Page 235 of 493 Top of Page Page 237 of 493