| | |
uncertain. If gestational agreements are voided or criminalized, | | individuals determined to become parents through this method will | | seek a friendlier legal forum. This raises a host of legal issues. | | For example, a couple may return to their home state with a child | | born as the consequence of a gestational agreement recognized in | | another state. This presents a full faith and credit question if | | their home state has a statute declaring gestational agreements to | | be void or criminal. |
|
| | | Despite the legal uncertainties, thousands of children are | | born each year pursuant to gestational agreements. One thing is | | clear; a child born under these circumstances is entitled to have | | its status clarified. Therefore, NCCUSL once again ventured into | | this controversial subject, withdrawing USCACA and substituting | | bracketed Article 8 of the new UPA. The article incorporates many | | of the USCACA provisions allowing validation and enforcement of | | gestational agreements, along with some important modifications. | | The article is bracketed because of a concern that state | | legislatures may decide that they are still not ready to address | | gestational agreements, or that they want to treat them | | differently from what Article 8 provides. States may omit this | | article without undermining the other provisions of the UPA | | (2002). |
|
| | | Article 8's replacement of the USCACA terminology, "surrogate | | mother," by "gestational mother" is important. First, labeling a | | woman who bears a child a "surrogate" does not comport with the | | dictionary definition of the term under any construction, to wit: | | "a person appointed to act in the place of another" or "something | | serving as a substitute." The term is especially misleading when | | "surrogate" refers to a woman who supplies both "egg and womb," | | that is, a woman who is a genetic as well as gestational mother. | | That combination is now typically avoided by the majority of ART | | practitioners in order to decrease the possibility that a | | genetic\gestational mother will be unwilling to relinquish her | | child to unrelated intended parents. Further, the term | | "surrogate" has acquired a negative connotation in American | | society, which confuses rather than enlightens the discussion. |
|
| | | In contrast, term "gestational mother" is both more accurate | | and more inclusive. It applies to both a woman who, through | | assisted reproduction, performs the gestational function without | | being genetically related to a child, and a woman is both the | | gestational and genetic mother. The key is that an agreement has | | been made that the child is to be raised by the intended parents. | | The latter practice has elicited disfavor in the ART community, | | which has concluded that the gestational mother's genetic link to | | the child too often creates additional emotional and | | psychological problems in enforcing a gestational agreement. |
|
|